Sidepodcast // All for F1 and F1 for all

Next race: Hungarian Grand Prix, Mogyoród
Class of the Field
Adam Barton

A Formula One fan since he was six, back while Häkkinen and Schumacher were having many an epic battle, Adam has seen a great deal. From German domination (twice), to British determination (once) and a Spanish invasion. A near compulsive fan who one day hopes to write about the sport for a living, outside of F1 Adam also authors his own blog One Guy's Opinion.

New kids on the block look to take charge // With Alonso, Webber and Button aging fast, who will step into their shoes in the coming years?

Published

We are a week into pre-season already, so I thought that it was about time that I woke up from my winter hibernation and get back to work. I came up with the idea of a few light-hearted top 5s and this week, I'm taking a look at the best potential drivers - younger drivers who will become the World Champions of tomorrow if and when the old guard are forced out of the top teams.

A quick note, although I rate Romain Grosjean as a driver, I haven't included him here; partly because he must focus on fixing his first lap issues before he is considered a top driver but also because I see him as ineligible in this category having been in what was ultimately, a race winning car last year. Right let's get down to business.

Luiz Razia - Brazil's new hope

This is the wildcard in this group as Razia had barely turned a wheel in an F1 car before preseason testing, but his pace is undeniable. Razia mounted a serious challenge for the GP2 title last year and, had Davide Valsecchi not dominated the early rounds because he had raced at the tracks before in GP2 Asia, he'd have strolled to the coveted feeder series' crown.

The Brazilian is the best of the next crop that the series has to offer and given a half decent car, he has the ability to get great results. Obviously that isn’t on the cards, as he’ll drive for Marussia in 2013. His main goal must be to survive the first year as Marussia has a tendency to not keep drivers for longer than a year.

If he can manage this, he could be the next thing, the next in a long line of Brazilians to be the hopes of a nation, and I think that given the opportunity, he could deliver their first world title since the late Ayrton Senna.

Valtteri Bottas - The next Flying Finn

Bottas during F1 testing in Jerez
Credit: Andrew Ferraro/LAT

Bottas is another unknown quantity but he does have considerably more experience in a Formula One car than Razia, and the experience he has had has been very impressive. He was consistently the fastest Williams in Free Practice 1 last year when he was in the car, beating team leader Pastor Maldonado.

Indeed his pace was so good, he was been expected to drive for Williams in 2013 since early in the 2012 season. Bottas looks like the real deal in an F1 car, and has been fast tracked through the feeder series to get here. But this raises another issue, this is a guy who hasn’t even driven in GP2; although we have seen that he has incredible pace, we have yet to see him in wheel to wheel combat in a competitive series; could this lack of experience cost him and turn him into an accident prone rookie?

To me, Bottas could be the best on this list, but, like Razia, with no F1 race experience to go on, it is hard to predict exactly how his career will pan out, especially with the huge step up from all other formulas to F1.

An extra point for those who argue that Williams had a race win in 2013 (this putting him in the same category as Grosjean), Williams had one race where they had true race winning pace, whereas Lotus were consistently fighting for podiums at least.

Sergio Pérez - Mexican magician

Pérez was without doubt the hot property of 2012. After a strong but not spectacular rookie campaign in 2011, he was placed on the outer ring of the radar. But just two races into 2012 he was placed squarely in the centre of the radar as target number one when he finished second in tricky wet conditions in Malaysia, fighting Fernando Alonso for victory. Suddenly it was well noted that he was a Ferrari protégé, especially with Felipe Massa faltering.

Scoring two more podiums at Montreal and Monza, the latter a mesmerising drive where he was in a different race to everyone else

Pérez continued to show great pace through the year, excelling with tyre conservation, and scoring two more podiums at Montreal and Monza, the latter a mesmerising drive where he was in a different race to everyone else, but couldn't quite bridge the gap to Lewis Hamilton.

But there are a couple of black marks on Pérez's record. He clearly had the fastest car in Malaysia, lapping seconds faster than Fernando Alonso at times, but couldn't get the job done. It would worry me now that he's at McLaren that the moment may be a bit too big for him, at least to start, and he may become the deer in the headlights.

More worryingly, Pérez struggled after he had signed for McLaren. He hasn't scored a point since he signed his big deal with McLaren, while teammate Kamui Kobayashi scored 25 points, including a maiden podium in Japan and three points finishes. This could further prove that the stage may be just too big for him.

There's no doubting Pérez's talent but there are flaws, such as his qualifying performance. My view is that Ferrari were wrong to cut ties with him but McLaren were wrong to sign him, at least at this stage in his career.

A Scot who can fly - Paul di Resta

I came into 2012 thinking of Di Resta as an average driver who was having his reputation bolstered simply because he was British. But even with a similar second season to his debut year, I have become more impressed with the Scot. A large chunk of my change in opinion is the realisation that Di Resta is regularly kept on a tight leash by the team who are trying to scrape for a few points when they are available. Far too often, Di Resta has been put on a strategy that requires a lot of tyre conservation in the hope that they may get lucky with a safety car or a mixed up race. Unfortunately, this stops Di Resta from showing what he can really do in a Formula 1 car when let loose.

Paul di Resta testing for Force India in Jerez
Credit: Sahara Force India Formula One Team

The reality is that Di Resta is a very consistent driver who will get exactly what the car is capable of getting. I would liken him to Rubens Barrichello at Ferrari, scoring good results every race but not breaking the bank. But given the right opportunity in a good car, Di Resta could be a sensation. He has the temperament that is required in a driver in order to mount a calculated title challenge but has also shown flashes of great speed, out-qualifying what his Force India deserved by a distance.

One factor not on Di Resta's side is his age. Although he'll only turn 27 early in the season, he's at an age where he must start making inroads on the top teams if he is not to be seen as a career midfielder. That said, his talent is unquestioned; had Force India created a car capable of fighting at the front of the midfield pack, I get the feeling that we may have seen more from this Flying Scotsman.

Hulk powers past the rest - Nico Hülkenberg

This is a guy that I really rate. This is the man that McLaren should have signed to replace Lewis Hamilton and when Sergio Pérez took that seat, Ferrari should have snapped him up immediately to be tutored under Fernando Alonso. Unfortunately for him, it took a little time to settle in at Force India and he only really started to shine late in the season when the ink was drying on contracts at the top teams.

It's a shame for him because I think he deserves his seat at the top table of the F1 season and could do some real damage in a car like the 2012 Ferrari or Lotus. Now he has moved on to Sauber he cannot afford to start slow as he has done at Williams and Force India but he should thrive with the opportunity to lead a team for the first time. With more and more uncertainty around Force India’s future, his move could be a good one, but now at a team with a tiny budget, he could get bogged down in the midfield if development stalls.

Hülkenberg was the man on form late in 2012; he had a great drive in Texas, showing his race craft in an epic battle with Kimi Räikkönen, eventually finishing eighth, and then put up a great fight for what could have been his maiden victory in the final round in Brazil. His hopes were eventually dashed by a couple of spins caused by faulty downshifts but he had done enough to provide a watershed moment. This, for me is the man to watch in 2013 and onwards.

All five men go into 2013 with a lot to prove for different reasons. The sad fact is that there simply isn't the space for them to all succeed in F1, with the majority of the top seats already taken for the next few years. The biggest casualty may well be between Paul di Resta and Nico Hülkenberg because there is a direct comparison between them. The one thing that's clear is that the man sitting third on this list; Sergio Pérez had better perform because the other four men are very worthy of a chance in a top team.




  • Hulk is definately at the forefront, no doubt. He the only one with a pole position so far.

    I've not seen the others in action due to GP2 being on Eurosport and then SkyF1 but I'd put Romain down for a championship in the future.

    I'm still not sure where the age cliff is though, Schumi managed a podium at 43 years old...

  • I think Hülkenberg is a star and I was surprised that di Resta was so close on performance. I think the two of them are capable of winning titles in the right car and McLaren should have taken one of them instead of Perez. I am not at all convinced by Perez but there are a few billion reasons to give him a try.

    Williams clearly rate Bottas highly and I get the feeling he will be good but I need to see a little more before could say he is championship material.

  • Of those in this group who raced last year I do think Hulk is the best of the bunch, but yes you're right Di Resta is being held back by some 'odd' strategies and it'd be nice to see what he can do unhindered.

    I'm a bit out of touch with GP2 so I've lost track of what Razia is up to, last I saw he was solid but not spectacular but an extra year or more of racing might've changed his game.

    Bottas.. lots of media hype but I've never seen him race.

    Arguably this article is a week or two too early - or more accurately Force India are too late! - as really Jules Bianchi should be in this group.

  • Arguably this article is a week or two too early - or more accurately Force India are too late! - as really Jules Bianchi should be in this group.

    And if they end up not signing him, they are idiots.

  • I'm surprised no one has mentioned the M word-Maldonado so far.

    Arguably this article is a week or two too early - or more accurately Force India are too late! - as really Jules Bianchi should be in this group.

    If I'm honest, I'd probably still have left Bianchi off the list because I don't know enough about him. I wish there was a way of separating driver from car so we knew who the fastest drivers were

  • I'm surprised no one has mentioned the M word-Maldonado so far.

    Too late! We already had a full post of Lukeh comparing Maldie to (a young, up-and-coming) the Legend that is Ayrton Senna http://gridwalktalk.com/?p=1552 .

    And to which I replied with a post that had sights lowered to a mere World Championship Driver, (a young, up and coming) Jody Scheckter.

    sidepodcast.com/p…-the-indefensible

    I think the theme in common with both posts is that it is going to take a lot more wrecked Maldie Mounts, as well as the mounts of the drivers he has crashed into, to knock enough sense into Maldie to be a WCD.....

  • I'm surprised no one has mentioned the M word-Maldonado so far.

    interestingly, if you'd asked "name five up and coming young f1 drivers", i cannot imagine he'd ever make my list. i think mainly because he looks older than he is, and it feels like he's been around forever.

    great article adam.

  • Thanks

    interestingly, if you'd asked "name five up and coming young f1 drivers", i cannot imagine he'd ever make my list. i think mainly because he looks older than he is, and it feels like he's been around forever.

    I agree, there's just something he lacks but it's not pace. Plus I wanted to get more under the radar for number 4 and 5 (Razia and Bottas).

    great article adam.

    Thanks SHOULD be four more (1 a week) until round 1 in Oz.

  • The only way Hulkenberg won't be in a Ferrari next season is if Massa manages to somehow beat Alonso, it's all very nicely set up for him right now, and he really does deserve it, probably the best young driver at the moment.

    I maintain Perez made the step up too early, he should have spent an extra year at Sauber because as he proved towards the end of the season, he's prone to making stupid mistakes and his consistency. Though spending some time with an experienced driver in Button is likely to be more helpful than with another inexperienced driver in Kobayashi.

    I think Paul di Resta has stagnated somewhat, or reached the heights of his potential. He started out close to Hulk at FI last year, but the latter improved while di Resta... didn't. Especially with the ever uncertain future of FI, I do wonder if he could be the next big casualty.

    And if they end up not signing him, they are idiots.

    If the reports about Karthikeyan are true, you almost have to feel sorry for them.

  • Unfortunately, number 5 on this list has no been dropped. Luiz Razia's backers do not know the frustration that they have caused me!

  • Unfortunately, number 5 on this list has no been dropped. Luiz Razia's backers do not know the frustration that they have caused me!

    what a frickin mess.

Comments closed to new entries.